Is your neighborhood really kid-friendly? In this episode, we explore how traffic and poorly designed streets are robbing children of their independence. Hear from two leading researchers on why kids can’t roam freely anymore and what needs to change to create safer, more accessible cities for all.
Show notes & links
- Traffic danger’s potential impact on children’s accessibility (the paper in question)
- Also listen to: Cities Book for Play
- Donald Appleyard – Livable Streets
- The City Is Here For You To Use: 100 easy pieces
Sponsored by:
Hi. We’re a full–service design cooperative – let’s work together to make your journey with a purpose successful.
this episode pairs well with…
003 Joanne Cheung – Cities Book of Play
Cities are sites of aspirations and identities, and ‘play’ can be a means for fostering community engagement. Architect and urbanist Joanne Cheung critiques the prevailing forms of community engagement, suggesting that they are often paternalistic and fail to adequately consider the agency of individuals and communities. Joanne further discuss the implications of power imbalances, the need for co-creation, and how play can act as a ‘scaffolding’ for discussing democratic representation. Play has often become commodified causing an unequal power dynamics in society. Joanne suggests the Cities for Play is but a scaffold in tackling very hard problems democratically, and calls for meaningful engagement through more community-oriented spaces for collective action and creativity.
Subscribe to the Newsletter
This post came from our weekly-ish newsletter. Feel free to signup below.
Guest Bio
Zahra Tavakoli is an urban and transportation planner with a Ph.D. in Civil Engineering from Polytechnique Montréal. Her work focuses on sustainable mobility, active transportation with a particular emphasis on accessibility and equity. Zahra is among the few researchers in North America developing tools to assess children’s independent mobility, ensuring cities are designed to be safer and more inclusive for all. Through her work, she tries to create urban environments that prioritize accessible and equitable mobility solutions for children and vulnerable populations.
Owen Waygood is a professor of sustainable transport at Polytechnique Montréal. He is interested in how to help shift society towards sustainable transport behaviours. As such, he studies how the built environment affects not just how we travel, but its impact on our lives through social, environmental, and economic impacts. He has also researched the role of information, in particular carbon dioxide, in transportation applications. Owen has published research on children’s travel (Canadian, British, Japanese and Swedish), life-cycle stages, cohort effects, information use for more environmentally friendly travel, and psychological impacts on the interpretation of CO2 information. He has three youngish children (11, 14, and 15) who love their independence.


“This paper examines how traffic danger could impact children’s accessibility to different destinations. A lot of studies about children’s mostly focused on going to the school or going to the park. But we were interested in understanding the full range of places that children go in their daily basis.
The results show that children’s accessibility is reduced up to 75 percent because of the traffic danger, which is something significant. These reductions not only affect their physical well being, but also affect their social interactions, their cognitive development as they lose a lot of opportunities to explore and engage with their environment.”
– Zahra Tavakoli
Top Ten Takeaways
- Traffic Danger Significantly Reduces Children’s Accessibility:
Traffic danger leads to up to a 75% reduction in children’s ability to access various destinations, impacting their independence, physical well-being, and cognitive development. - Urban Design Lacks Child-Friendly Infrastructure:
Many urban environments are not designed with children in mind, leading to dangerous conditions and limited opportunities for independent mobility, especially in residential areas with high-speed traffic. - Parental Fear and Overprotection Restrict Children’s Freedom:
Parents’ concerns about traffic danger, combined with societal pressures to always supervise children, have resulted in a decline in children’s independent travel compared to past generations. - Children’s Independent Travel is Essential for Development:
Allowing children to explore their environment independently is crucial for their social and cognitive development, yet modern urban design and policies often limit this freedom. - Urban Spaces are Viewed Differently by Adults and Children:
While adults prioritize formal activities (like school or parks), children place value on informal spaces (such as local stores, playgrounds, or open lots), which are often overlooked in urban planning. - Current Policies Remove Children from Danger Instead of Protecting Their Rights:
Instead of designing cities that are safe for children’s independent movement, many policies focus on removing children from risky environments, leading to further isolation and dependence on parents. - Tools to Measure Traffic Danger and Accessibility for Children are Needed:
Researchers are working on tools to assess how traffic and urban environments impact children’s accessibility. These tools can help cities prioritize interventions like safer streets, slower traffic, and better urban planning. - Cities Designed for Children Benefit Everyone:
Creating urban spaces that are safe for children, as the most vulnerable group, makes cities more inclusive and accessible for all residents, including the elderly and people with disabilities. - The Built Environment Hasn’t Changed Much, But Traffic Has Increased:
While the built environment has not dramatically changed since the 1980s, the increase in car usage and traffic danger has made urban spaces less accessible for children. - Increased Need for Parental Involvement Creates Stress:
Parents are often time-strapped and stressed due to the need to constantly accompany their children, especially in car-dependent environments, where children cannot move around independently.
Transcript
[00:00:00]
Zahra Tavakoli: A lot of studies about children’s mostly focused on going to the school or going to the park. But we were interested in understanding the full range of places that Children’s go in their daily basis. It’s not always about the traffic danger, but , Most of the time it’s about not enough opportunities to go.
Journey With Purpose: Welcome to Journey with Purpose episode 26. I’m your host, Randy Plemel. When I’m out about with my kids in the city, even New York. I am less afraid of the people on the street. And more afraid of people in cars. I see people in cars blow through stop signs. I see people in cars go over the speed limit. I see them not follow traffic lights. I seen them parked on a sidewalk. I seen them drive on the sidewalk. I see them back up. I hear them honking. There are some places in the city where we just would prefer not to go. And part of that [00:01:00] is because there’s too many cars and they’re too fast and they do all sorts of wacky things.
Today, we talk with two researchers out of Montreal about accessibility for kids throughout the city.
Zahra Tavakoli: I’m Zahra Tavakoli. I’m a recent PhD graduate from Per Technique Montreal. I live in Montreal and my research focuses on sustainable mobility and children’s accessibility. In the last few years, I’ve been working on developing a tool to measure how urban environments could affect children’s mobility and children’s accessibility, particularly in relation of traffic danger.
Journey With Purpose: Excellent. And Owen, tell us a little bit about yourself.
Owen Waygood: Hello, so I’m Owen Waygood. I am a professor of transportation at Polytechnique Montreal, in Montreal, and I’ve been doing research on children’s travel for nearly 20 years now. I did my PhD on children’s travel in Japan, and I was the lead editor on a book, called Transport and Child [00:02:00] Wellbeing.
Journey With Purpose: I was specifically interested in the paper, the traffic, dangerous, potential impact on children’s accessibility. I have two kids. I live in Queens, New York. We scooter, we bike, we bus, we subway. We even, we own a car, which we shouldn’t own a car in New York,, we are multimodal and the thing that I always tell people my folks and people who live outside of New York, especially in these days, they’re like, “Oh, New York is so dangerous. Yada, yada.” I say, well, you know what the danger honestly is, is when we’re out and about on the street, not from people, but people in cars. And so I’m super interested in this topic and love for you both to explain the paper to us and why you went about this research, Zahra, can you lead us, please?
Zahra Tavakoli: , this paper examines how traffic danger could impact children’s accessibility to different destinations. A lot of studies about children’s mostly focused on going to the school or going to the park. But we were interested in understanding the full [00:03:00] range of places that Children’s go in their daily basis.
So we identify different categories of destinations from educational, commercial, leisure, sports and so on. And then we measure the traffic danger on each street. And then to measure the accessibility, we counted the number of destinations that Children’s can reach. In the first scenario without applying the traffic danger like in a normal situation, and then we applied the traffic danger and we observed that how much the number of the destinations were decreased.
The results show that children’s accessibility is reduced up to 75 percent because of the traffic danger, which is something significant. These reductions not only affect their physical well being, but also affect their social interactions, their cognitive development as they lose a lot of opportunities to explore and engage with their environment.
Journey With Purpose: Owen do you want to fill in how did Zahra’s work and your work work together into a larger view [00:04:00] of, children’s accessibility in the city and safety?
Owen Waygood: I’ve been doing research on children’s independent travel for 20 years now. So, and, I myself have, I have three children who are now. Getting into the teenager years, but, I’ve lived it, I’ve studied it, and I examine it, and we know parents want to protect their children, and this is, justified, so we know from the literature that parents will restrict children’s independent travel. Independent travel being trips without a parent.
But, in that literature, it just says traffic danger. there was nothing about, okay, what, what is that traffic danger, and to what extent does it actually, reduce the lived environments of children, So, what Zahra was saying about we can look at, you know, where children can go without traffic danger, And that, if you will, is a potential, right? That’s a potential of where children could go. And then we say, okay, but in the reality, when you take into account the traffic danger, their lived environment shrinks [00:05:00] significantly, which can probably help explain why children nowadays just don’t have the same freedoms that, that they had in the past.
Journey With Purpose: You get enough Gen X parents and the conversation almost always leads to, “Hey, remember when we were kids and we would just run amok in our neighborhood?” And our only rules, like my only rules was Hey, you can’t go past some of these streets. And when the street lights turn on, you better come home. Across my friend group, and this is super anecdotal, but, from people who live in, New York City, all the way to, the suburbs in, Midwest, U S it seems like there’s this trend of not feeling like we can give our kids that free range movement. I’m interested in why do you think that has happened? Is it just anecdotal or has something changed from the 1980s to now?
Owen Waygood: So, it’s a good question and it’s a difficult one and it’s not just [00:06:00] one thing that’s changed.
The built environment hasn’t necessarily significantly changed in that period of time, but it is spreading out. And that spreading out is leading to more people driving, and when more people drive, there’s more traffic danger, and then parents start becoming concerned.
Okay. From the sociology research they also highlight that the, idea of a perfect parent has changed. So a perfect parent used to be that you gave children the skills and the ability to get out and explore and be free and be a normal citizen in the city. But the perfect parent now often is viewed as somebody who’s always there to protect the child. And so there’s social pressures that parents report feeling that they can’t let their children go because the expectation of other parents is that they should always be there protecting their child.
Then in another area, if you will, the policy objectives has gone from [00:07:00] protecting children’s right to go places to removing children from danger. And so the policies have been applied, aren’t necessarily protecting children’s right to go places, they’re saying, okay, let’s get children out of traffic. So if the children just stay at home all the time, the job is done because you’ve protected the child, but the problem is that you’ve stolen their rights to go places by themselves.
What was observed
Journey With Purpose: I love to hear on what you observed and what you heard from both the kids and from adults.
Zahra Tavakoli: We observed this in our paper and in our results that, confirmed The most important reasons that we observed through our study. It was all coming from the traffic danger, but mostly from the speed. for example, in the peripheral boroughs in Montreal, where they’re like mostly residential and not that much Opportunities to go for Children. The role of the high speed streets was the most important ones that affect and influence the level of accessibility for [00:08:00] Children.
Journey With Purpose: Is there any others like surprising? results from your work, from your studies.
Owen Waygood: In our work, we, asked parents we asked children and we asked experts because we often exclude children from these discussions because we think oh Well, I was a child at some point I remember, but it seems like we don’t. So when you, talk to parents, also this aspect that parents think their children need to be in activities all the time.
There is , some research that basically shows that as cars became more and more prevalent, children basically got removed from the public sphere. And so then the only way for children to be active and to have social interaction was to then take them to these activities. So parents really focus on these very formal activities, but then when we ask children, it’s just all these informal spaces that they want to go and meet up with the neighborhood kids, like whether it’s an abandoned lot, it’s a basketball net in a back alley, those types of [00:09:00] places are what children were valuing, but that’s not what the adults, even the experts, are necessarily putting value on.
And so then when we make, these policies and even when we think about how a street should be designed, we’re doing it from our adult perspective and sometimes this idea that, oh, all children should be escorted. Well, if your approach is that all children should be, escorted, then maybe you shouldn’t be surprised that the end result is all children are dependent on parents and that they have to beg their parents who are already time strapped in order for them to go and meet friends. Right, which is for me, like a terrible end result that we’ve, we’ve arrived.
(V/O CAN YOU SHARE A LITTLE MORE ABOUT THE FINDINGS – I’M SUPOER INTERESTED IN HOW YOU BEGAN TO SEGMENT OUT DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE CITY THROUGH USAGE AND DESIRABILITY, FROM BOTH AN ADULT AND CHILD POINT OF VIEW.)
Journey With Purpose: Can you share a little bit more about the findings? I’m very interested in how you began to segment out different parts of the city, through how people use it and what they desire from both the adult and children’s point of view.
Zahra Tavakoli: One of our main ideas to start this research was that a lot of national surveys ignore Children, [00:10:00] mostly because the information about Children’s are coming throughout the second hand information from the adults, which make it easier for us to not really accurate to measure children’s actual behavior.
And the different perspectives with these two groups were fascinating because parents mostly refer to formal activities, going to the schools, community centers. Parks, but for Children, even when they are mentioning the formal activities that there are some available data about that they were mentioning going to the toy stores or bakeries or chocolate places or grocery stores. These sorts of Different perspectives was adding a lot of value to our research because it was the first time that we understand the weighting from the perspective of children as the actual users.
So this perspective between the weighting of the destinations between the value of the destinations from the perspective of Children’s and from the perspective of parents was really [00:11:00] fascinating for us.
Journey With Purpose: . It’s almost like, let’s look at the city instead of from like adult height, see it from, you know, one meter or 30, eight inches above the ground. So it’s like, let’s, let’s lower it down. Let’s look at it with like a childlike thing. I love that. , I’m a child of the eighties and there was definitely places in the back of the park where you just go and, you throw rocks and, you know, get dirty and, there was probably dumb stuff we did, but you know, I’m still here. It’s super interesting to see, The difference, how, how both kids and adults are seeing the city.
So Zahra, you talked about that. this was a tool and If you could wave a magic wand and you, you know, get more funding and get more time and get more thing. Is this something that you could say, take to other cities and, could walk score, give you a bag of money and this could be part of walk score 2. 0 or maybe, maybe the, federal, department transportation could do it. Is that the [00:12:00] aspiration here?
Zahra Tavakoli: well, yes, I believe that, uh, what other accessibility measures are doing is that they have the same value for all the destinations and also for all the streets, but the idea of this tool is coming from the fact that not all the destinations are equal for Children for travel because well, Children have their own needs. They mostly travel to the local destinations. They have limited walking abilities. So , not all those measures are suitable for Children and my magic land. Go through and apply this traffic measures like this traffic penalty scores on each streets and then evaluating Children’s destinations and finding the place of interventions.
The most important part of this tool is for identifying the place of interventions and prioritizing those interventions. for example, finding the pedestrian zones or finding the most dangerous [00:13:00] places based on this assessment of the tool.
It’s not always about the traffic danger, but , Most of the time it’s about not enough opportunities to go, , specifically in the residential areas that a lot of opportunities are not between Children’s walking distance like a reasonable walking distance. So prioritizing the mixed land use or more walkable neighborhoods is something that I would add to this. Yes.
Journey With Purpose: Owen, if you could wave a magic wand and, a bag of money comes from somebody like what, could this tool be, for you?
Owen Waygood: It’s a great question. I actually used WalkScore as the example when I was proposing the project, because I think a lot of people are familiar with WalkScore as a, as a way to measure, are there, daily needs that are within a walking distance? and then knowing again from the children’s research that, okay, it could be walking distance, but that doesn’t mean that a child’s going to be allowed to go there, or that the child themselves feel comfortable to cross [00:14:00] those. So waving a magic wand, as Zahra is saying, that we would want to, be able to measure these, these it does is it allows us, well, this measure of traffic danger that we would be able to apply it in different cities. We, we do hope to continue the research in that direction. And then the things that Zahra has done, like, if you just look at it purely the kind of that walk score side is saying, okay, walk score it’s a great tool for, for adults and their needs. There’s bars, there’s all these other aspects in there. but Okay, what about for for Children and having an understanding that some of those destinations are more valuable Children? and so having something if you were waited by that by that need or that want be a really crucial, tool.
And when I was thinking about this project, one of the things I wanted was it’s not just for the policy makers like we work with the city of Montreal. This is City of Montreal helped finance this work, but I would ideally like, is that [00:15:00] parents could look and be like, oh, okay, I’m thinking about moving to this neighborhood, like how, how does it rank in terms of this, if you will, like the child walk score?
Because a lot of places, unfortunately, that people think, they’re like, oh, like I have a kid, so I need to move out to this area, that they kind of perceive as being child friendly, because there’s more house space. But then in reality, you’re basically imprisoning your child. those destinations, destiny, like in this, in the suburbs, unfortunately, are going to really limit the opportunities that your child has to, unfortunately, live a full life, if you will, that they will be locked into a dependence upon you, which increases stress for parents, because all parents want to provide for their children, but then they’ve kind of locked themselves into this situation where they have to be the one taking their kids.
There’s the very famous Japanese, , TV show, Hajime no Otsukai, which is in English, your first [00:16:00] errand and then on Netflix, I think it was called Old Enough. That whole aspect that kids can go by themselves. They can, but one of the critical things is that traffic danger, and people will say, oh, what about the social danger? But they’re, they’re linked, right? Like when you have a super busy street, nobody wants to be on that street, and nobody’s gonna have a conversation.
There’s great research, by Donald Appleyard in New York, showing how people’s kind of social connections and what they believe is their living space reduces as your level of traffic goes up. And when we reduce that traffic danger, it’s not just children that benefit, there’s all these other parts of the population that benefit.
And when people are out there, the majority of people are good people. And when you have lots of good people out there, socially safer. So there’s, there’s so many of these ties in there.
Building state capacity
Journey With Purpose: I get excited for approaches like this because, I work a lot with, federal state and local governments. And as you know, they are [00:17:00] starved of capacity and capability. And so anytime that we could use and bring tools that can help them make good choices.
And I get inspired by the part around here where something like this could help both policymakers and like you said, the parents or, maybe school officials advocate for different interventions because this starts to become evidence. I wonder if part of the next steps of, this tool could be linking, analyzed street and now here’s a range of potential interventions from, speed humps and speed controls to, daylighting intersections to, filtering and things like that.
Here’s where the current ground truth is. Let’s try a couple of interventions and see what might happen. And , if you do this, this sort of [00:18:00] thing might happen.
Owen Waygood: Yeah. Randy, that’s honestly where, where we’re at right now. In the work that we’re doing with two cities, so Montreal and West Mountain, the next steps , are basically building prioritization tools on where we need to intervene to reduce traffic danger. And then, depending on the source of the traffic danger, then saying, okay, what is the type of intervention that needs to be implemented?
Zahra Tavakoli: Yeah, as Owen explained, I believe that this tool is a perfect tool for finding the place of interventions but also prioritizing the different interventions. And I believe that it could. The whole intervention could include the redesigning streets or coming through improving the infrastructure or creating policies to encourage, walking and biking. We believe that this can highlight the importance of designing cities for children because if it’s safe for children as like the most vulnerable group It would be safe for everybody.
Creating safe and [00:19:00] accessible city for children would benefit everyone when we design streets that are safe for the most vulnerable group of the society like children, it’s great, like a more inclusive environment for all the people. So I hope these kind of works encourage a shift to our city planning that considers the needs of children and also by extensions, the building of the community for all.
Owen Waygood: If you talk to any parent, they’ll, they’ll know about traffic danger , but it was abstract, And what we’re trying to do with these tools is actually make it a concrete concept and be able to present it in a visual manner through these maps so that the policymakers and the parents can actually see how that’s impacting the children’s lives in a more transparent way. That it’s not just some abstract idea that remains up in the sky. And hopefully by doing that, that children will be directly taken into account when we do our transportation planning and that we will, we’ll stop ignoring this, part of the [00:20:00] population and assuming that planning for parents to drive around isn’t necessarily better thing for children’s lives.
Re-Introductions
Owen Waygood: my name is Owen Waygood. I’m a professor of transportation engineering at Polytechnique Montreal, in Canada. I am a father of three children who are now 11, 14, and 15, and I’ve been working on children’s independent travel and how it impacts their lives for about 20 years now.
Zahra Tavakoli: I’m Zahra Tavakoli. I’m a transport engineer in Polytechnique Montreal, and my research focuses on sustainable mobility, children’s accessibility, and children’s independent mobility.
Summation & outro
Journey With Purpose: All right. That was journey with purpose episode 26, my special, thanks to Zara and Owen for hopping on the phone with me.
As Adam Greenfield says, the city is for us to use and it’s for all of us. It’s for us in wheelchairs it’s for us in strollers. It’s for us and [00:21:00] bikes. It’s for us on the sidewalk. It’s for us walking around it’s us in scooters. Yes cars have a place in our mobility spectrum. But. As we continue to re define and roll back the primacy of cars and our life, especially in urban built-up areas. We need to make sure that we designed for all the people, including kids.
So, thank you all for listening today. If you want to support the podcast, you can like this episode, you can share it with your friends. You can rank us heart us. Give us a 5.0 rating. Hopefully on Spotify. Or apple . All those non-monetary benefits help. You can also buy some pamphlets on jwp.news.
As usual, the points of view, the beliefs and the comments don’t necessarily reflect the beliefs, comments, or ideas of our employers. But you knew that.
We wish everyone a special day [00:22:00] and see you on the internets.
More podcasts
[powerpress_playlist]













