NYC Congestion Pricing

On January 5th, 2025 congestion pricing came to NYC. Rather…the Manhattan Central Business District Tolling Program was finally turned on. For the next few weeks there’s going to be wall to wall stories about this, how it’s somehow unfair, the hacks and workarounds people will do, and the lawsuits.


Who’s coming to Manhattan?

Of everyone commuting to the Manhattan CBD, only 24% are doing it by motor vehicles (which includes trucks, FHV’s, private cars, etc), but only 6-11% of those commuters to the Manhattan CBD are doing it by car. So if we can persuade the car drivers to use other means, then we can free up space to make deliveries faster, allow for faster FDNY response times, and make it easier for people who can’t mode-shift to get around by their car.

Only 6-11% of commuters?

What’s the cost of not doing congestion charge?

TK


Our streets are full because “X”

  • There are too many Uber/Lyft/FHV cars on the road, therefore we don’t need congestion charge.
  • You’ve added too many bike lanes, therefore we don’t need congestion charge.

A common refrain is that our streets are full, but because of some other reason, therefore weldon’t need congestion pricing to reduce that congestion.

First, this acknowledges that there’s a supply and demand problem with our streets: we have limited amount of streets and no matter how we apportion space on our streets, the demand is higher than the supply of street. Second, the amount of for-hire vehicles on NYC streets is less than the peak back in 2019/2020. Additionally, the city has effectively capped the amount of taxis, green taxis, Ubers, Lyfts, etc. which are on our streets.

The thing which is driving congestion is the increase in personal vehicles and freight vehicles – big trucks to small package trucks to gig economy last-mile vehicles. After the easing of COVID lockdowns, the amount of river crossings went up, predominantly caused by private vehicles which track with the increased number of vehicle registrations in the five boroughs.

A geometry problem

We fundamentally have a geometry problem: we have limited street, the numbers of vehicles are increasing, and the size of vehicles have been steadily increasing. So to move people and goods via vehicles in the densest part of the US using the least efficient means of moving them (cars) will create gridlock.

And that’s what we’ve been seeing prior to enacting Congestion Pricing.

I already pay for entering Manhattan

  • I already pay a toll to enter the Lincoln/Holland/Midtown Tunnel, I don’t want to pay another toll.

My response is…so?

My car fees pay for the roads

False.

The fees for the opportunity to drive involve vehicle registration, drivers license, insurance, gas, and probably parking. Those fees don’t go to building and improving roads.

The budget for building and maintaining roads predominantly comes from the general fund, money which comes from income tax, sales tax, payroll tax, etc. Some road funding certainly comes from gas tax, usage fees, etc. but in New York State, at least 35% of that funding comes from the General Fund. And people who don’t have cars but have drivers licenses fund streets.

This argument quickly falls flat since roads are funded by many sources, and the fees above are explicitly tied to owning and operating cars, which isn’t a fundamental right. But, because Manhattan’s CBD is so dense, not paying your fair share for getting something for free isn’t fair to those same people who pay taxes and don’t drive this quickly gets preposterous.

Won’t my deliveries become more expensive?

This intuitively makes sense, but it’s a cat

Freight vehicles will $3.60 and $21.60 per trip, depending on the truck size and time of day. Less traffic means deliveries become quicker and more cost efficient.


Where does the money go?

The funds raised from selling bonds backed by congestion charge tolls go to the capital program. This builds stuff that we need: new buses & subway cars, new subway lines, new infrastructure, elevators, etc. all capex. See the above map showing where the money will go.

This is separate from the operating budget: funds from payroll tax, fare box & general funds. This budget will probably need more funds since the cost of running all this will continue to go up. There are too many people in my replies complaining that the MTA won’t do anything with the money they get from congestion charge. Well, the MTA literally has a list with what to do with the congestion charge money.

The MTA has a simple website explaining where all the money will go to, and you can go read the 2025-2029 MTA Capital Plan (read the PDF) and see where the money will go.

There is a huge amount of people who think this is going into a slush fund or evaporating. Their misinformation is a combination of bad communication, and people not listening since this has been in discussion since 2019 (and really since the 1970’s).


First,

On program complexity

Another big misunderstanding in congestion charge is that you get charged for crossing the boundary every time. Generally you get charged once a day, the toll has a peak and Overnight amount, and there’s discounts when you go through a tolled bridge/tunnel. It gets complicated if you are in a taxi/Lyft/Uber or a commercial truck.

It’s unfortunately complex, which wouldn’t be my choice as a simpler tolling design would reduce people’s mental calculations. This is why simpler policy design is better: people can’t do the mental math and they quickly think that you are trying to pull a fast one on them. Simple is always better.

Data, forthcoming

The MTA is legally required to do annual reporting on the impact of congestion charge, including how it’s affecting not only traffic, but pollution, and a host of other indicators. MTA head Janno Lieber (disclosure: at a previous employer I consulted for Lieber while he was at another company) intimated that they will try to share impact of the congestion charge at monthly MTA board meetings, with the next one being January 27 and 29, 2025.

I’m sure we will all be waiting for some first official data on the impact, but we should all have some discipline to see that it’s going to be a full six to 12 months before we see any clear impact. By the way: president-elect Trump (ugh, a sequel?) will be sworn in on January 20th, and I would certainly advise the MTA to have some set of data published prior to this date to get ahead of any potential silliness the new administration might want to pull regarding congestion charge, since it does need DOT approval.